Canidae vs Taste of the Wild Dog Food Comparison

Google+ Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr +

Choosing the best dog food for you and your pet can be a difficult task. While there are many not so great options, there are also a ton of great options that keep your pup happy and healthy. With thousands of different dog food formulas created to solve a variety of issues, choosing one can be overwhelming. Don’t worry – you aren’t alone.

Two very popular dog food brands are Canidae and Taste of the Wild. Both of these brands provide healthy dog food that comes in a number of formulas. Learn more about the benefits and flaws of each to help decide what is best for your pooch.

Canidae Dog Food

Canidae is a dog food manufacturer that is based in Brownwood, Texas that has been in business since 1996. The company is committed to quality ingredients and sources said ingredients from farms and ranches across the United States. At Canidae’s Ethos Pet Nutrition facility (Brownwood), ingredients are tested to make sure that they meet the company’s high standards.

Coupon Details

This deal is good for 20% off your first order when you sign up for Chewy.com’s autoship program.

Update: All orders above $49 will receive FREE SHIPPING

Since Canidae is a small, family-owned business, the company likes to support other businesses like itself. When possible, Canidae sources ingredients from family-owned farmers and ranchers, as well as working with distributors and retailers that are family-owned.

Like previously mentioned, Canidae creates healthy dog food by using some of the best ingredients out there to provide your dog with nutritious food. With quality fruits and vegetables, and even legumes, you can be sure that your dog is getting all the vitamins and minerals it needs. With healthy protein ingredients, such as lamb and bison, your dog will be provided energy that it needs to make it through the day, without consuming excess calories that it doesn’t need.

This dog food producer has a line of grain-free dog foods that are great for dogs with sensitive stomachs or allergies to grains. These formulas are also limited ingredient foods, which means that they only contain a few select ingredients, all of which are chock-full of vitamins and minerals that your dog needs.

One really great thing about Canidae is that the company also produces dog treats, so you can not only feed your dog great food, but also give them high quality treats that are just as nutritious as their regular food.

Top Canidae Dog Food Formulas:

  1. Canidae Life Stages All Life Stages Formula Chicken, Turkey, Lamb and Fish Dry Dog Food

  2. Canidae Grain-Free PURE Land with Bison Dry Dog Food

  3. Canidae Grain-Free PURE Sea with Salmon Dry Dog Food

Taste of the Wild Dog Food

Taste of the Wild is known for its slogan, “It’s the balanced diet that nature intended.” The brand lives up to its name with premium, grain-free dog foods that are made to mimic your dog’s ancestral diet. While the company selects only top-of-the-line ingredients, it also assures pet owners that its foods are safe by putting all of its products through rigorous safety and quality testing. Giving your dog food from Taste of the Wild means that you can rest assured that your pet will have the food it was born to eat.

Coupon Details

This deal is good for 20% off your first order when you sign up for Chewy.com’s autoship program.
Update: All orders above $49 will receive FREE SHIPPING

With fruit and vegetable ingredients, as well as high quality proteins, your dog will get nutritious food that won’t pack on a ton of fat. The vegetables and fruits in each bag provide your pet with antioxidants, vitamins and minerals. Prebiotics and probiotics can also be found in each bag.

Taste of the Wild offers grain-free dog food formulas, which is great for dogs that have allergies to grains or have sensitive stomachs. Since grains aren’t part of what dogs would eat in the wild, you can rest assured that Taste of the Wild won’t include them in the foods it produces for your beloved pet.

Taste of the Wild offers a variety of different protein options in their dry dog foods. From venison to beef to quail to fish to eggs, there is a protein option for every dog owner and pooch. Keep in mind that you will want to find something that your dog enjoys eating and gives them the energy they need to make it through the day.

Top Taste of the Wild Dog Food Formulas:

  1. Taste of the Wild High Prairie Dry Dog Food

  2. Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream Dry Dog Food

  3. Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Dry Dog Food

Comparing the Two Brands

While both Canidae and Taste of the Wild are known as quality dog food brands, there are very obvious differences between the two that may be important for you as a dog owner.

Price

Price can be important when determining what dog food you want to purchase. You will want to get a food that is good for your pooch, but you will also want to get the most bang for your buck. Let’s take a look at the top three dog food formulas for each brand to see what our options are.

For Canidae:

  1. Canidae Life Stages All Life Stages Formula Chicken, Turkey, Lamb and Fish Dry Dog Food is about $1.28 per pound.

  2. Canidae Grain-Free PURE Land with Bison Dry Dog Food is about $2.49 per pound.

  3. Canidae Grain-Free PURE Sea with Salmon Dry Dog Food is about $2.49 per pound.

Canidae food averages about $2.09 per pound.

For Taste of the Wild:

  1. Taste of the Wild High Prairie Dry Dog Food is about $1.49 per pound.

  2. Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream Dry Dog Food is about $1.63 per pound.

  3. Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Dry Dog Food is about $1.66 per pound.


Taste of the Wild food averages about $1.59 per pound.

Looking strictly at price, Taste of the Wild food will offer a better value, but what about the other key factors in selecting a dog food?

Ingredients

Selecting food with quality, nutritious ingredients is very important. While many dog foods are loading with different ingredients, the top five or so will tell you what the main ingredients in the formula are.

Canidae:

In Canidae Life Stages All Life Stages Formula Chicken, Turkey, Lamb and Fish Dry Dog Food, the top ingredients are chicken meal, turkey meal, lamb meal, brown rice and white rice. Unfortunately, meat meals aren’t as nutritious as the protein themselves, but these three meal ingredients will give your dog the energy it needs. White rice is usually frowned upon in dog foods, so that isn’t the best find.

Canidae’s Grain-Free PURE Land with Bison Dry Dog Food’s top five ingredients are bison, lamb meal, sweet potatoes, peas and chickpeas. Bison is a great number one ingredient as it is a whole protein source. The bison makes the lamb meal more excusable. Having vegetables as the other top ingredients is very important, as those ingredients give your pet a lot of different vitamins and minerals.

The top five ingredients in Canidae’s Grain-Free PURE Sea with Salmon Dry Dog Food are salmon, salmon meal, menhaden fish meal, sweet potatoes and peas. Salmon being the number one ingredient is great, because not only is salmon a protein source, but it is also full of oils and fatty acids that are good for your pooch. The other fish meals are great for providing more protein. Peas and sweet potatoes will give your dog a great dose of vitamins and minerals.

Taste of the Wild:

Taste of the Wild High Prairie Dry Dog Food has buffalo, lamb meal, chicken meal, sweet potatoes and peas as its top five ingredients. The three proteins, one of which is a whole protein will give your dog energy. Peas and sweet potatoes are full of nutrients that dogs need to survive.

The Pacific Stream Dry Dog Food from Taste of the Wild has salmon, ocean fish meal, sweet potatoes, potatoes and peas as its top five ingredients. Salmon is very healthy for dogs as it not only provides protein, but also oils and fats that are key for your pet. Ocean fish meal will add an extra boost of protein. Sweet potatoes and peas provide important nutrients, but potatoes are typically just added to make your pet fuller on the food.

Taste of the Wild’s Sierra Mountain Formula Dry Dog Food’s top ingredients are lamb, lamb meal, sweet potatoes, potatoes and peas. Lamb and lamb meal are great sources of protein for your pet. Unfortunately, potatoes are generally frowned upon as ingredients in pet foods as they don’t have many nutrients and are often viewed as fillers to make your pet fuller. The peas and sweet potatoes will provide many vitamins and minerals to your dog, however.

Overall, these two companies ingredients aren’t all that different, but what about the nutritional value of each dog food?

Nutritional Value

Making sure that your pet has nutritious food is very important. Let’s take a quick look at what both Canidae and Taste of the Wild have to offer in terms of nutritional value.

Canidae:

Canidae Life Stages All Life Stages Formula Chicken, Turkey, Lamb and Fish Dry Dog Food

  • Crude protein: 24% minimum

  • Crude fat: 14.50% minimum

  • Crude fiber: 4% maximum

  • Calories: 468 kcal per cup

Canidae Grain-Free PURE Land with Bison Dry Dog Food

  • Crude protein: 25% minimum

  • Crude fat: 15% minimum

  • Crude fiber: 4% maximum

  • Calories: 474 kcal per cup

Canidae Grain-Free PURE Sea with Salmon Dry Dog Food

  • Crude protein: 32% minimum

  • Crude fat: 18% minimum

  • Crude fiber: 4% maximum

  • Calories: 496 kcal per cup

Taste of the Wild:

Taste of the Wild High Prairie Dry Dog Food

  • Crude protein: 32% minimum

  • Crude fat: 18% minimum

  • Crude fiber: 4% maximum

  • Calories: 370 kcal per cup

Taste of the Wild Pacific Stream Dry Dog Food

  • Crude protein: 25% minimum

  • Crude fat: 15% minimum

  • Crude fiber: 3% maximum

  • Calories: 360 kcal per cup

Taste of the Wild Sierra Mountain Dry Dog Food

  • Crude protein: 25% minimum

  • Crude fat: 15% minimum

  • Crude fiber: 4% maximum

  • Calories: 338 kcal per cup

Final Verdict - Which One is the Best?

Now, it is time to choose what dog food is best for you. While there is no clear winner, there are pros and cons for both dog food brands.

Canidae offers dog foods at more different price ranges, but, overall, it is more expensive than Taste of the Wild’s dog food selection. While price isn’t the most important factor, it is a serious one to consider. If you are looking for more bang for your buck, would probably want to select Taste of the Wild.

As for nutritional value, Taste of the Wild offers foods with fewer calories per cup than Canidae’s foods. You don’t want to give your dog too many calories, but you do want to keep them full. Taste of the Wild’s foods are just as nutritious as Canidae’s, but with fewer calories so you don’t risk packing additional weight onto your dog. Unfortunately, Canidae doesn’t really stand a chance when compared to Taste of the Wild on price and nutritional merit.

One major downfall for Canidae is that Taste of the Wild can give your dog most of the same things, but for less. Overall, Taste of the Wild is probably the better choice between these two brands. Taste of the Wild offers many different dog food formulas, so you are bound to find something that works for your pet. There may be a few ingredients to watch for in Taste of the Wild’s formulas, such as potatoes, but, overall, each formula is nutritious and inexpensive.

The overall winner has to be Taste of the Wild.

Share.

About Author

Leave A Reply