Wellness vs Blue Buffalo Dog Food Comparison

Google+ Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr +

Finding the best food for your dog can be a stressful task. With dozens of different brands in hundreds of different formulas, it can take a lot of research to find the dog food that will work best for your beloved pooch. Comparing a few brands at a time can be helpful, so in this article we are going to see how Wellness brand and Blue Buffalo dog foods stack up.

When it comes to selecting a dog food, you will want to compare the ingredients in each formula, as well as the nutritional value that is derived from those ingredients. While price isn’t the most important aspect when selecting a dog food, it is important to get a good value. If the nutritional value and price match up, you might have found the perfect dog food formula for your pooch.

Remember that not all dogs have the same needs. You may want to consider things like health issues when trying to come up with a great choice for your dog. For example, dogs with skin and hair issues may require dog foods higher in omega fatty acids or fish oils, while dogs with joint issues may need foods with high levels of copper and vitamin C.

Wellness Dog Food

Wellness brand strives to make the healthiest dog foods possible. The company’s mission is to help you keep your pet healthy and happy so they live a long life. Wellness does this by making foods with natural nutrition.

Wellness foods contain wholesome and natural ingredients with a boost of super nutrients including antioxidants, prebiotics, probiotics and omega fatty acids. The company doesn’t use any artificial colors, preservatives, flavors or ingredients.

To ensure that all of the dog foods produced by Wellness meet the company’s strict quality standards, they put the food through strict quality assurance testing. The company selects only the best ingredients that are then handled with care to make sure that all the ingredients are safe. Wellness uses only the most trust-worthy suppliers to gain the ingredients they need for the foods it produces, and then Wellness tests every ingredient to make sure that they are the best available.

Popular ingredients in Wellness dog food formulas include chickpeas, ground flaxseed, carrots, apples, blueberries and sweet potatoes, just to name a few. These ingredients provide a number of vitamins and minerals that your dog needs to be healthy. Apples contain pectin, while blueberries contain vitamins A and C, as well as antioxidants. Carrots contain fiber and beta carotene. Other quality ingredients will provide your pooch with additional health benefits.

Top Wellness Dog Food Formulas:

  1. Wellness TruFood Baked Blends Adult Recipe Lamb, Chickpea and Turkey Liver Grain-Free Dog Food Formula
  2. Wellness Grain-Free Complete Health Adult Whitefish and Menhaden Fish Meal Recipe Dry Dog Food Formula
  3. Wellness Grain-Free Complete Health Adult Lamb and Lamb Meal Recipe Dry Dog Food Formula

Blue Buffalo Dog Food

Blue Buffalo is one of the most well-known dog food brands on the market. With its ads targeted at pet owners who want to feed their dog the way it would’ve eaten in the wild, many people have had success with this dog food brand.

Coupon Details

This deal is good for 20% off your order when you order from Chewy.com and sign up for their autoshipment.

Update: They are now offering an free shipping on any orders over $49.

Wellness foods contain wholesome and natural ingredients with a boost of super nutrients including antioxidants, prebiotics, probiotics and omega fatty acids. The company doesn’t use any artificial colors, preservatives, flavors or ingredients.

To ensure that all of the dog foods produced by Wellness meet the company’s strict quality standards, they put the food through strict quality assurance testing. The company selects only the best ingredients that are then handled with care to make sure that all the ingredients are safe. Wellness uses only the most trust-worthy suppliers to gain the ingredients they need for the foods it produces, and then Wellness tests every ingredient to make sure that they are the best available.

Popular ingredients in Wellness dog food formulas include chickpeas, ground flaxseed, carrots, apples, blueberries and sweet potatoes, just to name a few. These ingredients provide a number of vitamins and minerals that your dog needs to be healthy. Apples contain pectin, while blueberries contain vitamins A and C, as well as antioxidants. Carrots contain fiber and beta carotene. Other quality ingredients will provide your pooch with additional health benefits.

Top Wellness Dog Food Formulas:

  1. Wellness TruFood Baked Blends Adult Recipe Lamb, Chickpea and Turkey Liver Grain-Free Dog Food Formula
  2. Wellness Grain-Free Complete Health Adult Whitefish and Menhaden Fish Meal Recipe Dry Dog Food Formula
  3. Wellness Grain-Free Complete Health Adult Lamb and Lamb Meal Recipe Dry Dog Food Formula

Blue Buffalo Dog Food

Blue Buffalo is one of the most well-known dog food brands on the market. With its ads targeted at pet owners who want to feed their dog the way it would’ve eaten in the wild, many people have had success with this dog food brand.

Coupon Details

This deal is good for 20% off your order when you order from Chewy.com and sign up for their autoshipment.

Update: They are now offering an free shipping on any orders over $49.

Blue Buffalo has a few different product lines that you should be aware of when looking into a new dog food. The Blue Freedom line is all natural and grain-free, which is ideal for dogs that have gluten allergies. The Blue Basics dog foods are limited ingredient formulas. Limited Ingredient Diets, LIDs, are great for dogs that have food sensitivities, as they are generally made without all the foods that trigger sensitivities, such as eggs, corn, wheat, dairy and soy. Blue Wilderness dog food is a meat-rich food that provides your dog that wolf-like diet with more protein and no grain.

With something for literally everyone’s pooch, Blue Buffalo is a great dog food brand. Not only are there a number of different formulas that you can choose from, but the company strongly believes that they should make nutrient-rich dog foods that give pets all they need for energy and growth. Blue Buffalo also uses only high quality ingredients, especially proteins.

Blue Buffalo doesn’t like to “cut corners” by using meat by-product meals. The protein sources in Blue Buffalo dog foods will always be high quality, such as deboned chicken, lamb, beef or fish. Plus, with many protein sources available, you are sure to be able to find something that is great for your dog and that it enjoys.

Top Blue Buffalo Dog Food Formulas:

  1. Blue Buffalo Basics Limited Ingredient Grain-Free Lamb and Potato Recipe Adult Dry Dog Food Formula
  2. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Adult Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food Formula
  3. Blue Buffalo Freedom Adult Beef Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food Formula

Comparing the Two Brands

Both of these dog food brands offer high quality products, but which one should you pick for your lucky pooch? Let’s take a look at the two side-by-side.

Price

While price isn’t everything, it is very important when selecting the food you feed your dog. You should look for a product that gives you the most bang for your buck. To do this, you will need to look at the price, as well as the nutritional information, of each brand’s dog food formulas. With so many options, it can be hard to decide. Let’s break it down.

For Wellness

  1. Wellness TruFood Baked Blends Adult Recipe Lamb, Chickpea and Turkey Liver Grain-Free Dog Food Formula is about $3.43 per pound.
  2. Wellness Grain-Free Complete Health Adult Whitefish and Menhaden Fish Meal Recipe Dry Dog Food Formula is about $1.98 per pound.
  3. Wellness Grain-Free Complete Health Adult Lamb and Lamb Meal Recipe Dry Dog Food Formula is about $1.98 per pound.

Wellness dog foods average about $2.46 per pound.

For Blue Buffalo

  1. Blue Buffalo Basics Limited Ingredient Grain-Free Lamb and Potato Recipe Adult Dry Dog Food Formula is about $2.07 per pound.
  2. Blue Buffalo Wilderness Adult Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food Formula is about $1.90 per pound.
  3. Blue Buffalo Freedom Adult Beef Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food Formula is about $1.90 per pound.

Blue Buffalo averages about $1.95 per pound.

Going off only price, you would notice that Blue Buffalo is about 50 cents cheaper per pound than Wellness dog foods. Since price isn’t the only important aspect of choosing the right dog food for you, let’s take a look at what you will find in the bag.

Ingredients

The ingredients in your dog’s food are very important. You will want to look for ingredients that are nutrient-dense, and the first five ingredients will tell you what most of the food is made of. The better the ingredients, the better the food.

Wellness

Wellness’ TruFood Baked Blends Adult Recipe Lamb, Chickpea and Turkey Liver Grain-Free Dog Food Formula features lamb, turkey meal, peas, tapioca flour and chickpeas as the top five ingredients. The lamb and turkey meal in this dog food give it a good source of protein. Peas and chickpeas also made in into the top five ingredients, which means that your dog will get a good dose of fiber, potassium and vitamins A, B and C, as well as magnesium and phosphorus.

The top five ingredients in Wellness Grain-Free Complete Health Adult Whitefish and Menhaden Fish Meal Recipe Dry Dog Food Formula are whitefish, potatoes, peas, menhaden fish meal and chickpeas. With a large amount of fish in this dog food formula, your pooch will get the Omega-3 Fatty Acids it needs for healthy skin and coat. Potatoes are often viewed as a filler ingredient, however. Filler ingredients are put in dog foods to make your pet feel fuller.

Wellness Grain-Free Complete Health Adult Lamb and Lamb Meal Recipe Dry Dog Food Formula contains lamb, lamb meal, potatoes, peas and dried ground potatoes as its top ingredients. Unfortunately, potatoes are two of the main ingredients in this dog food. Since potatoes are seen as filler in dog foods, having two of the top ingredients being potatoes doesn’t bode well for this dog food formula. The lamb and lamb meal are quality protein sources, however. The peas will also provide your pet with a number of different vitamins and minerals it needs to stay healthy.

Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo’s Basic Limited Ingredient Grain-Free Lamb and Potato Recipe Adult Dry Dog Food Formula’s top five ingredients are deboned lamb, potatoes, peas, pea starch and lamb meal.  The lamb and lamb meal offer a quality source of protein, but the potatoes in this food are a little concerning as they are just there to make your dog feel fuller. Peas are healthy and provide a number of vitamins and minerals to your dog, but pea starch isn’t known for doing anything other than filling your dog up. This food seems to have a lot of fillers in it.

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Adult Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food Formula features three protein sources as the top three ingredients. Deboned chicken, chicken meal and turkey meal are the main protein sources in this high protein dog food. After those ingredients, tapioca starch and peas round out the top five. Peas are a great source of vitamins and mineral. Tapioca starch is a healthier alternative to potatoes in dry dog food.  Tapioca acts as a filler, but has more fiber and vitamins and minerals than potatoes.

The top ingredients in Blue Buffalo Freedom Adult Beef Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food Formula are deboned beef, chicken meal, tapioca starch, potatoes and peas. The fact that there are two different types of proteins in the first five ingredients is great, because your dog will get a well-rounded serving of protein in every bowl of food. The tapioca starch and potatoes are fillers with little nutritional value, but they do provide a few vitamins and minerals. The peas are nutrient-dense and will give your dog all sorts of minerals, such as magnesium.

Overall, each of these dog foods contain great sources of protein, however, each one seems to contain at least one filler. As far as ingredients go, these two dog food brands are pretty even.

Nutritional Value

Wellness

Wellness TruFood Baked Blends Adult Recipe Lamb, Chickpea and Turkey Liver Grain-Free Dog Food Formula

  • Crude protein: 29% minimum
  • Crude fat: 17% minimum
  • Crude fiber: 4.5% maximum
  • Calories: 433 kcal/cup

Wellness Grain-Free Complete Health Adult Whitefish and Menhaden Fish Meal Recipe Dry Dog Food Formula

  • Crude protein: 26% minimum
  • Crude fat: 12% minimum
  • Crude fiber: 5.25% maximum
  • Calories: 422 kcal/cup

Wellness Grain-Free Complete Health Adult Lamb and Lamb Meal Recipe Dry Dog Food Formula

  • Crude protein: 26% minimum
  • Crude fat: 12% minimum
  • Crude fiber: 5.5% maximum
  • Calories: 422 kcal/cup

Blue Buffalo

Blue Buffalo Basics Limited Ingredient Grain-Free Lamb and Potato Recipe Adult Dry Dog Food Formula

  • Crude protein: 20% minimum
  • Crude fat: 14% minimum
  • Crude fiber: 6% maximum
  • Calories: 354 kcal/cup

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Adult Chicken Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food Formula

  • Crude protein: 34% minimum
  • Crude fat: 15% minimum
  • Crude fiber: 6% maximum
  • Calories: 409 kcal/cup

Blue Buffalo Freedom Adult Beef Recipe Grain-Free Dry Dog Food Formula

  • Crude protein: 24% minimum
  • Crude fat: 14% minimum
  • Crude fiber: 6% maximum
  • Calories: 337 kcal/cup

Final Verdict

After reviewing all of the facts, it is hard to select a winner. Your best bet is to review all the information and select what works best for you and your pet.

Blue Buffalo provides lower calorie foods at a cheaper cost, but there are generally more fillers in these dog foods. While fillers aren’t the worst thing in the world, it is disappointing to see so many fillers used so frequently in Blue Buffalo’s foods.  If, for some reason, your dog needs an exceptionally high amount of protein, you will want to look specifically at Blue Buffalo’s Wilderness dog food line, as it has the highest amount of protein out of all of the foods we looked at. Otherwise, you may want to consider looking at Wellness dog foods.

Wellness brand dog foods are slightly more expensive than Blue Buffalo, but the additional value may just be worth it. Wellness tends to use less filler products than Blue Buffalo and the foods contain more nutrient dense fruits and vegetables than Blue Buffalo. Wellness dog foods do have a higher calorie content, so you may want to check with your vet to make sure you don’t overfeed your dog and find yourself with a weight issue later.

Regardless of what brand you go with, you can be assured that your dog will have a high quality dog food that will leave them happy and healthy. Best of luck in selecting the dog food that works best for both you and your pup.

Share.

About Author

Leave A Reply